Rochester, NY · Est. 1958

The Color of
Done Right.

For over six decades, Mayer Paint & Hardware has been Rochester's destination for premium paints, professional-grade tools, and the kind of expert advice you won't find at a big-box store.

Visit Our Store Explore Products
Interior of Mayer Paint & Hardware showing paint displays and hardware shelves
65+
Years Serving
Rochester
10K+
Products In
Stock Daily
100%
Color
Matching
Premium Paints ◆ Professional Tools ◆ Expert Color Matching ◆ Hardware & Plumbing ◆ Key Cutting ◆ Screen Repair ◆ Paint Supplies ◆ House & Auto Paint ◆ Premium Paints ◆ Professional Tools ◆ Expert Color Matching ◆ Hardware & Plumbing ◆
What We Carry

Everything for
your next project

From a single can of paint to a full contractor supply run — we stock the brands professionals trust and the variety homeowners need.

Interior and exterior paint cans and rollers on display

Paint & Stain

Interior, exterior, and specialty paints from top brands. Custom color matching available.
Professional hand tools and power tool accessories on a hardware store shelf

Tools & Hardware

Hand tools, power tool accessories, fasteners, adhesives, and everything in between.
Plumbing supplies and fixtures arranged on store shelving

Plumbing

Fittings, valves, pipes, fixtures, and repair parts for residential and light commercial use.
Electrical supplies including wire, outlets, and light fixtures on display

Electrical

Wire, outlets, switches, lighting, boxes, and electrical accessories for any job.
Key cutting machine and duplicate keys on a hardware counter

Key Cutting

Same-day key duplication for homes, cars, and padlocks. Fast, precise, and affordable.
Window screen frames and repair materials on a workbench

Screen Repair

Window and door screen repair and replacement. Custom sizes cut to fit.
Exterior of Mayer Paint & Hardware storefront on Winton Road in Rochester
Our Story

A Rochester
institution

Mayer Paint & Hardware has been a fixture on Winton Road since 1958. What started as a small neighborhood paint shop grew into one of Rochester's most respected hardware destinations — not through advertising, but through the kind of consistent, honest service that turns first-time customers into lifetimes of repeat business.

We're not a franchise. We're not trying to be the cheapest option online. What we are is the store where you can walk in, talk to someone who actually knows paint, and leave with exactly what you need — and the confidence that it'll work.

1958
Year Founded
226
Winton Road N
since day one
65+
Years of
service
Why Mayer

The difference
is in the details

Same-Day Service

Key cutting, paint mixing, screen repair — most services completed while you wait. No appointments necessary.

Expert Color Matching

Bring us any color — a fabric swatch, a photo, a chip from your old trim — and we'll match it precisely with our spectrophotometer.

Contractor Quality

We stock the same professional-grade products used by tradespeople across the Rochester area. Volume pricing available.

Real Advice

Our team has decades of combined experience. We'll tell you what you actually need — not what's on sale. That's the Mayer way.

Ready to start
your project?

Stop by during business hours or give us a call. We're here to help you get it right the first time.

(585) 288-7665 Get Directions
Find Us

Visit our store

Address

226 Winton Rd N
Rochester, NY 14610

Business Hours

Monday – Friday 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Is this your business?This is my business